actually, square roots are always positive. the definition of a square root is that it's an absolute value.
i.e. sqrt of (-1)*(-1) = |-1| = 1
My real response to this topic though is that I dread such silliness in interviews. In my current position I was asked a stupid question in a 5-on-1 interview and basically said what I thought about the question but still got the job - so maybe that was the correct answer. Hope I don't ever find myself desperately needing a job and having to endure this silliness again.